A Brotherhood Mutual Partner
Brotherhood specializes in protecting your church or related ministry.
We Protect and Serve Your Ministry
We are here to give your church peace of mind.
Serving Illinois and Missouri
We understand your ministry's needs.
What Our Customers Say
We highly recommend Gearhart for your church's Insurance needs. They are quick to respond to our needs, very thorough and go above and beyond to satisfy us! The ladies in the office are very knowledgeable, kind and willing to go the extra mile to meet our needs.
Carbondale, IL
We are truly blessed to have the Gearhart Group taking care of our insurance needs. Not only are they efficient and capable in every way, their kindness, caring and love for Christ shines through in every interaction we have with them.
We experienced a strong storm in August 2019 and the church sustained some major damage
as a consequence. I contacted our Gearhart Church Insurance Group concerning our policy
and what steps needed to be taken. They explained our coverages and started the claims
process immediately. Brotherhood Mutual was amazing to work with from start to finish.
They were very understanding and dedicated to our satisfaction as the policy owner. Even
though it took longer than anticipated to complete the scope of work, they were
extremely patient and we communicated often about the progress of the project. I have
always been told that the true character of an insurance company is tested and proven
during the claims process.
Gearhart Church Insurance Group and Brotherhood Mutual have earned my utmost respect for
their commitment to customer satisfaction and service.
Fairfield, Illinois
It has been a pleasure working with Gearhart Insurance Group. They have been knowledgeable about our policy and very responsive if we have questions. If your church is looking for a representative to take care of your churches insurance needs. I highly recommend Gearhart Insurance Group.
Galesburg, Illinois